Peloton Shoes for Wide Feet: Top 9 Picks for 2023

Fact Checked

Tonya McIntosh

Tonya McIntosh—The main person behind TGFFitness as its Founder and Chief Editor. Get to know more about Tonya

OUR EDITORIAL GUIDELINES

In addition to testing, reviewing and recommending the best products, we may earn a small commission if you purchase through our affiliate links.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Peloton bikes are excellent for cranking out some cardio sessions at home. However, if you have wide feet like me, you have another problem coming your way – getting the right shoes!

I’ve competed in cycling competitions in the past. And indoor peloton bikes have long been my go-to cardio workouts in my home gym. So, I’ve had my fair share of trying the wrong shoes leading to blisters, discomfort, and foot pain in my initial years.

The good news is that this struggle has helped me narrow down on the best Peloton cycling shoes for wide feet.

9 Best Peloton Cycling Shoes for Wide Feet

Best Overall Performance

Sidi Genius Mega 7

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The Sidi Genius Mega 7 remains my favorite pick as the best overall wide cycling shoe for Peloton bikes. They cover broad feet perfectly. And you don’t have to shop for sizes bigger than your usual pairs.

The shoe features a Millennium 4 Carbon Composite Sole for efficient power transfer, a Caliper Buckle with a two-way ratchet closure for a secure fit, and High-Security Velcro straps that won’t slip.

The Soft Instep Closure System and padded tongue eliminate pressure points, ensuring comfort during long rides.

Pros:

  • Microfiber surface for a snug fit.
  • Works well with both LOOK Delta and SPD designs.
  • Ideal for both men and women.

Cons:

  • Slightly heavier than competing designs.
  • No vents in the lower sole.

Key Features and Benefits

Sidi’s trademark Techno-3 Push system allows you to enjoy comfort while clipping in or out of your Peloton bike. And the lug sole allows you to shift quickly between SPG pedals or Peloton’s LOOK Delta design.

All-Around Performance

SHIMANO SH-RP1

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The Shimano SH-RP1 is an all-around performance road cycling shoe with Shimano quality, comfort, and function.

It features a comfortable fit and perfect support for pedaling, dual hook and loop straps that provide a reliable and secure fit, and a lightweight glass fiber-reinforced nylon sole.

The shoe is compatible with both SPD and SPD-SL cleats and has a wider cleat adjustment range. Customers have found the shoe to be comfortable, practical, and durable.

Pros:

  • Double straps and hook design for extra grip.
  • Extra lightweight sole.
  • Easy cleat adjustment.

Cons:

  • Not compatible with LOOK Delta.
  • The clip takes time to attach.

Key Features and Benefits

The RP-1 is an excellent choice for intensive cycling and power-packed pedaling. The dual hooks ensure that your pedal grip remains strong and stable. If you ever go cycling outdoors, the reflective strip on the back heel provides additional visibility to tailgaters.

Dual Cleat Compatibility

STRADA 200

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The Strada 200 is a cycling shoe designed for dual compatibility with Look Delta or SPD cleats, making it ideal for use with Peloton bikes that have a double cleat design.

Its quick and easy 2-strap + buckle design ensures a secure and comfortable fit while locking the heel in and avoiding hotspots and pressure points.

The Strada 200 is suitable for spin class, road biking, and touring, providing versatility for different lifestyles.

Pros:

  • Great for indoor Peloton and outdoor cycling.
  • Soft upper made from vegan leather.
  • Vented sole that keeps feet cool and dry.

Cons:

  • Not as durable as designs like the Sidi Genius Mega. 7

Key Features and Benefits

The Strada 200’s greatest strength is its dual compatibility. However, it’s also a versatile cycling shoe thanks to the stable design that promotes easy power transfer. Also, it works with almost any type of clip hole.

Even the price is affordable, given the premium features you can enjoy with this shoe.

Best for Design, Durability

Sidi Men’s Alba 2 Mega

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The Sidi Men’s Alba 2 Mega is a road cycling shoe that offers the stiffness of carbon, reliable support, and supple uppers at a more affordable price point than many other Sidi offerings.

The shoe features a wide, anatomically curved strap and a soft, thermo-formed EVA pad that evenly distributes pressure over the instep area.

The Mega version of the shoe is designed for those with wider feet, offering extra width across the ball of the foot, more volume, a high instep, and a wider heel cup.

Pros:

  • Adjustable system for a customized fit.
  • Politex material resists rips and fading.
  • Reinforced heel cup enhances power transfer.
  • Enhances shoe longevity.
  • Carbon composite sole provides rigidity.
  • Suitable for those with wider feet.

Cons:

  • Shoes may run larger than expected.
  • Higher price compared to other shoes.
  • Only available in black.

Key Features and Benefits

The Alba 2 Mega combines comfort and durability with its Politex upper and adjustable Soft Instep Closure System.

Its reinforced heel and Twelve Carbon Composite sole ensures optimal power transfer. Designed for wider feet, it offers extra room and volume.

Despite its high-end features, it’s more affordable than many other Sidi models.

Versatile Comfort

Venzo Bicycle Riding Shoes

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The Venzo Bicycle Riding Shoes are a versatile and comfortable option for cyclists with wide feet.

These shoes feature a quick-drying, highly breathable mesh and synthetic upper, textile lining with a removable sock liner, and a low-cut construction for a light, fast fit and feel.

They are compatible with Look Delta and Shimano SPD-SL cleats, making them suitable for road riding, commuting, touring, and spin classes.

Pros:

  • Available in 14 sizes starting from 6.5 to 14.5.
  • Compatible with all cleat designs.
  • Breathable mesh for extra comfort and easy drying.

Cons:

  • Cleat screws may shake during long cycling sessions.

Key Features and Benefits

The synthetic upper on the Venzo shoes makes them lighter and more comfortable than other expensive cycling shoes.

The cleats feature a floating system that can rotate across 9 degrees, promoting easier movement. Also, the triple-strap design ensures that your wide feet remain snug inside the shoe for the ideal fit.

High-Cadence Riding

Lake Men’s Cx238

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The Lake Men’s Cx238 is an evolution of the CX237, designed for high-cadence riding. It features a comfortable fit with increased toe pitch and heel lift, allowing the foot to expand under high pedaling pressure.

The shoe has a stiff, lightweight Race carbon fiber sole for power transfer and a durable full-grain leather upper with a heel panel and toe bumper. It also includes mesh panels for ventilation.

The wider forefoot design provides relief during high-pressure riding, allowing cyclists to focus on the road ahead.

Pros:

  • The superior sole is made of 100% carbon.
  • The premium leather surface is water resistant.
  • The lacing design also straps in with a BOA lock for more stability.

Cons:

  • Not great for outdoor cycling.
  • Carbon sole’s hard surface is uncomfortable during long sessions.

Key Features and Benefits

Of the 15 standard sizes, the Cx238 has five variants that are specially designed for wider feet. Also, the shoes weigh a negligible 1.8 lbs making them super light and easy on the legs.

The BOA locks allow you to tighten or loosen your laces quickly.

Comfort and Performance

Ergo 5 Mega Carbon

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The Sidi Ergo 5 Mega Carbon is a high-end cycling shoe designed for comfort and performance.

It features a Twelve Carbon composite sole for stiffness and tuned flex, a Soft Instep Closure System to prevent hotspots and a wider last with extra room across the forefront of the shoe.

Pros:

  • Soft insoles for maximum comfort.
  • Techno-3 Push system for exact fit.
  • Strong velcro straps for stability and easy removal.

Cons:

  • Matte surface scratches easily.
  • Heavy and bulky design.

Key Features and Benefits

The Ergo 5 Mega Carbon has an additional 4mm across its width for people with broader feet. The high in-step and soft in-sole ensure that your heel remains comfortable and always protected.

Also, the carbon-composite sole was built for durability. So, expect this pair to last for many more cycling sessions.

Versatile Road Cycling

Fizik R5 Carbon

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The Fizik R5 Carbon, also known as Tempo Overcurve R5, is a versatile and comfortable cycling shoe that cyclists of any level can use.

It has an asymmetrical construction and a durable micro tex upper for a comfortable and consistent fit.

The shoe has a BOA IP1 dial and a Velcro strap for a fine-tuned fit. The R5 Nylon composite outsole is designed to be comfortable for long rides without compromising pedaling efficiency.

Pros:

  • 50+ unique sizes designed for men and women.
  • Composite material for comfort and durability.
  • Microtex upper for additional mobility and flexibility.

Cons:

  • Absence of sole vents.
  • Heavy shoe.

Key Features and Benefits

The R5 Carbon combines synthetic materials, Microtex, carbon, and polyamide to create a shoe that screams comfort without compromising quality.

The Velcro strap and BOA lock offer convenient strapping and unstrapping. And the Overcurve design ensures that even people with long feet can cycle for hours on end without discomfort.

Women’s Ergonomic Fit

SHIMANO RP Women

Check Latest Price

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

The SHIMANO RP Women’s cycling shoes are designed for women with wide feet, offering a comfortable and ergonomic fit.

These versatile shoes are compatible with both two and three-bolt cleats, making them suitable for outdoor road riding and spin classes.

The shoes feature a women’s-specific last for enhanced comfort during long rides, and their lightweight design ensures optimal performance.

The SHIMANO RP Women’s shoes are an excellent choice for those seeking a practical and stylish option for their cycling needs.

Pros:

  • Made of extra light carbon composite materials.
  • Special design and curvature created for women’s feet.
  • Adjustable for Peloton bikes and most outdoor bikes.

Cons:

  • The toe box is spacious but may be too big for some women.
  • Not available in many colors.

Key Features and Benefits

The synthetic outsole makes the SHIMANO RP a comfortable but lightweight shoe. On the other hand, the carbon sole ensures that it retains a stable grip on the soles. The BOA lace is micro-adjustable. So, you can tighten it even better than ordinary men’s cycling shoes.

Peloton Shoes for Wide Feet: Comprehensive Buying Guide

Here are some features to look for when purchasing cycling shoes from Peloton.

Compatibility with Peloton

Peloton bikes come with 3-hole cleats or with dual-hole designs. Ensure that your shoe supports either of these cleat designs. Double-check whether your shoe is designed for the LOOK Delta design or the SPD system.

Correct compatibility will allow you to continue using the same shoes even when you decide to upgrade or switch your Peloton bike one day.

For instance, the SHIMANO RP1 is an excellent cycling shoe but does not support the LOOK Delta cleat design.

Shoe Width Sizes Available

Reliable sellers will always put up appropriate size charts for the shoe you’re browsing. Check to see if wide variants are available before purchasing.

For example, the Lake Cx238 has a 6.5 Wide, 8.5 Wide, 9 Wide 10 Wide, and 10.5 Wide design. These five-width sizes come in addition to the 14 other standard sizes they offer for normal shoe sizes.

Quality and Durability

Go for shoes made of durable and high-quality materials. Carbon soles offer the maximum resilience to wear and tear. And leather surfaces stay in place longer than synthetic material.

BOA clasping systems and hard toe-boxes are both signs of a well-built shoe that will last you in the long run.

Power Transfer and Performance

Carbon-composite soles are stiff and hard enough to let you drive more power into the pedals. Arch support is another vital design element that will protect your heel and ankles and prevent injury.

The STRADA 200 and SHIMANO RP1 are both good examples of stable design and ergonomic comfort. 

Comfort and Fit

Adjustable straps and BOA-type locks allow you to fiddle with the straps quicker. So, you get more comfort and versatility out of the shoes. A wider toe box like the SHIMANO RP will allow free movement and spacious comfort inside the shoe.

Breathability

Shoes with mesh fabrics allow fresh air to pass through, keeping your feet fresh and ventilated. Heel vents in some shoes also help your feet stay fresh and cool.

Look for materials like mesh that allow parts of your shoe to stretch and let in the air during your workouts. Some synthetic materials also support ventilation and passage of air.

Weight and Flexibility

Look for lightweight cycling shoes that will help you expend less energy during extended sessions on your Peloton. 

For instance, the Ergo 5 Mega Carbon is excellent for width and power but weighs almost 4 lbs, making it the wrong choice for heavy cycling sessions. 

The synthetic material and Overcurve designs allow your feet to bend freely, move easily, and prevent unnecessary heel strain.

Aesthetics and Design

Appearance should not be your top priority when buying cycling shoes. However, some shoes come with attractive design options that you can pick to match your overall look.

The Fizik Tempo R5 comes with rich colors, including Metal Black and Yellow Fluo, which can really make your shoe pop in the scene.

Cost and Value

Stick to cycling shoes that offer value for money. Compare its features with the price point and see if the benefits correspond to the price tag.

Investing in a high-quality Peloton bike shoe may help you avoid buying multiple shoes in the future.

FAQs:

What is considered a wide foot?

The typical proportion of human feet is about twice as long as the width. Let’s say you wear a size 8 shoe. You can expect the width to be slightly less than 4 inches. Anything more than 4 inches can be considered wide.

How do I know if I need wide width shoes?

Discomfort, calluses, or corn developing along the edges of your feet may indicate that your shoes do not fit you properly. You may need wide-width shoes if most of the discomfort is across the breadth. 

Should I size up or down for Peloton shoes?

The right shoes for Peloton bikes should remain true to your original size. Cycling shoes like the SIDI Genius Mega ensure that the design accommodates wide feet while still measuring the same dimensions as your normal shoe size.

Can I wear wide-width shoes with normal feet?

Yes, you can. But expect some discomfort. The additional space in width will leave empty space inside the shoe creating the risk of injuries too. It’s best to wear normal-sized cycling shoes if your feet are not wider than normal.

Do I need Peloton-specific shoes to ride a Peloton bike?

Yes. You will need cycling shoes with cleats and clip-ons that match the lock on the Peloton pedal. However, you don’t have to stick with the Peloton brand shoe. There are other more reliable, better-designed, and more affordable options available (like the ones on this list).

Can I stretch my Peloton shoes?

Peloton shoes do not stretch as well as other cycling shoes. Most of the materials in Peloton shoes consist of fabric and plastic parts, making them less elastic and stretchable.

Are Venzo cycling shoes good for wide feet?

Yes. Venzo cycling shoes often make excellent solutions for wide feet. Most designs come in a dozen or more sizes. Plus, the breathable mesh and comfortable synthetic ensure that your wide feet aren’t cramped for space or air.

Which bike shoes are wide?

There are tons of wide cycling shoes on the market today. However, designs like the Sidi Genius Mega 7, the SHIMANO RP series, and the Fizik R5 give the most comfort, performance, and durability among other wide cycling shoes.

Are Peloton shoes supposed to be tight?

Your Peloton shoes should wrap around your feet snugly. But they shouldn’t be so tight as to cause pain or discomfort for your feet.
The proper fit will give you grip, mobility, and better pedaling motion as you exercise. However, Peloton shoes that are too tight will lead to long-term injury instead.

Why do my Peloton shoes hurt my feet?

Experiencing foot pain with Peloton shoes implies they’re either the wrong size or shoes for your feet. Shoes designed by Peloton work well for normal-sized feet. However, people with wide feet will have trouble exercising with these shoes.

Final Verdict

Being blessed with wider-than-normal feet comes with the struggle of enduring ill-fitted shoes. However, finding the right Peloton cycling shoes for wide feet will ensure that your cardio sessions remain effective and enjoyable.

Experience the blissful comfort and superior cycling performance with Peloton shoes designed for wider feet when you pick one of the stellar shoes listed in this guide!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Was this helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!
Chief Editor
Tonya McIntosh

Hello there! My name is Tonya McIntosh, and I’m the Founder and Chief Editor of TGFFitness. I’m also a NASM-certified Nutrition Coach and Personal Trainer. With eight years of experience under my belt, I’ve found that one of the most common issues my clients struggle with is remaining consistent.

Finding your main motivator to keep going is easier said than done for Keep Reading.

Share this article